Understanding and Automating Counterspeech

29 September 2021

Online

This workshop is convened by Giving Voice to Digital Democracies, a research project which is part of the Centre for the Humanities and Social Change, Cambridge, and organised by Stefanie Ullmann, Cambridge. It is funded by the Humanities and Social Change International Foundation.

Summary

Online hate speech and the spread of misinformation continue to increase, notably exacerbated by the Covid-19 pandemic and recurring national shutdowns. According to a review published by The Alan Turing Institute in 2019, between 30-40% of people in the UK have witnessed harmful content and 10-20% have personally experienced abuse online. Moreover, recent statistics released by the government on hate crime show that the number of hate crimes in England and Wales has increased steadily over the last six years. Research suggests that there is a link between online hate speech and real-life acts of discrimination and violence. And while awareness of the problem increases on societal as well as governmental and corporate levels, current approaches are still insufficient as the spread of hate speech and disinformation continues. Most social media platforms still follow a mainly reactive approach to harmful content and even if more content were deleted, it remains questionable whether removal or blocking is the best way to engage with this problem. At the same time, companies like Apple, Microsoft and Amazon report an increasing amount of verbal abuse directed at their virtual personal assistants Siri, Cortana and Alexa. This has equally brought into question how voice agents should counter this form of toxic communication. 

An increasing body of research from different fields such as linguistics, philosophy of language, media and communication studies, law and policy, computer science and information engineering has been analysing the role and functions of counterspeech as a means of successfully combatting hate speech, verbal abuse and misinformation. Among the first to study counterspeech, in 2015/2016, in the context of harmful language online were researchers at the Dangerous Speech Project. In 2017, Facebook began to launch and promote several counterspeech initiatives to fight hate speech on its social media platform. In descriptive and experimental studies, researchers have found that counterspeech on social media is not only a suitable way of engaging with harmful speech but is also shown to have a positive effect on bystanders, and other users are more likely to comment, like or reproduce someone else’s counterspeech. More recently, experts from the fields of computer science and information engineering have begun to apply computational methods to the processing, generation and evaluation of counterspeech. 

This workshop brings together experts from different fields in academia (philosophy of language, sociology, law, media and communication studies, peacebuilding and conflict studies, computer science), political activism and industry to further the conversation and address some of the most pressing questions as well as computational approaches to counterspeech. 

Speakers

Amalia Álvarez-Benjumea (Max Planck Institute for Research on Collective Goods)

Babak Bahador (George Washington University)

Cathy Buerger (Dangerous Speech Project)

Christos Christodoulopoulos (Amazon Alexa AI)

Joshua Garland (Santa Fe Institute)

Rae Langton (University of Cambridge)

Sina Laubenstein (No Hate Speech Movement Germany)

Punyajoy Saha (Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur)

Erin Saltman (Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism)

Kenneth S. Stern (Bard Centre for the Study of Hate)

Nadine Strossen (New York Law School)

 Lynne Tirrell (University of Connecticut)

Bertie Vidgen (Alan Turing Institute)

 

Queries: please contact Una Yeung

11:00 – 11:10

Welcome and introductory remarks (Giving Voice to Digital Demoracies team)

11:10 – 12:40

Talk by Amalia Àlvarez-Benjumea (Max Planck Institute for Research on Collective Goods), followed by a discussion with Sina Laubenstein (No Hate Speech Movement Germany) and Erin Saltman (Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism)

12:40 – 14:00

Lunch Break

14:00 – 15:30

Talk by Christos Christodoulopoulos (Amazon Alexa AI), followed by a discussion with Punyajoy Saha (Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur) and Bertie Vidgen (Alan Turing Institute)

15:30 – 15:45

Break

15:45 – 17:15

Talk by Lynne Tirrell (University of Connecticut), followed by a discussion with Rae Langton (University of Cambridge) and Babak Bahador (George Washington University)

17:15 – 17:30

Break

17:30 – !9:00

Talk by Cathy Buerger (Dangerous Speech Project), followed by a discussion with Nadine Strossen (New York Law School), Ken Stern (Bard Centre for the Study of Hate) and Joshua Garland (Santa Fe Institute)

19:00 – 19:10

Concluding remarks (Giving Voice to Digital Demoracies team)