Media of Hate: Representations of Religious Persecution and Repression in Early Modern Europe

3 October 2019 - 4 October 2019

SG1/SG2, Alison Richard Building, 7 West Road, Cambridge, CB3 9DT

Registration for this conference is now open. There is a flat rate fee of £10 which includes lunch and refreshments.  One-day registration is also available.  

Please email conferences@crassh.cam.ac.uk if you would like to be kept informed about the event, or have any other questions. 

 

Convenors

Alison Knight (University of Cambridge)

Daniel Trocmé-Latter (University of Cambridge)

 

Summary

The religious turmoil of the early modern period saw widespread repression of minority religious groups across Europe, involving degrees of violence that prompted large-scale migration across national borders. Those suffering persecution at home often sought refuge in likeminded nations, yet in striking parallel to the refugee crises of today, migrant groups often faced considerable prejudice within their host nations (if not outright violence). Evidence for such religious prejudice can be found across the continent in a variety of media. By the 1590s in England, for example, domestic reaction to religious refugees came to a violent head, with several anti-alien riots erupting in London. Multiple libels, pamphlets, and tracts directed aggressive language toward religious refugees, accusing foreigners of feigning their religion for the sake of migration, overcrowding the capital, and engaging in illegal trade. In cities across Europe, such as the German Protestant city of Strasbourg, officials had to take disciplinarian approaches to moderating religious violence; according to the early historian of the Reformation, Johann Sleidan, Strasbourg city councillors had to 'command [citizens] to leave others in peace in their churches', at pain of expulsion from the city.

Media of Hate brings together scholars from the fields of early modern literature, religious studies, history, musicology, and art history in order to explore the various media used to communicate and represent discrimination and distrust towards religious minorities across early modern European contexts, from Dutch Protestant and French Huguenot refugees, to Jewish communities, and Catholic recusants. What distinctions, if any, emerge between singing discrimination, painting it, or writing a poem about it? On what were people’s fears fundamentally based (nationality, cultural habits, language)? Is it possible to discern similarities and differences in xenophobic material from country to country? What effect did hate speech have on policy-making and public opinion? Through this conference, we hope to delineate trajectories regarding hate in the early modern public sphere, arguing for the power that media could wield in shaping historical events and policies, as well as the considerable role that popular concerns about foreigners and belonging played in shaping the literature, art, and music of the period.

 

Sponsors

            

Supported by the Centre for Research in the Arts, Social Sciences and Humanities (CRASSH), the Society for Renaissance Studies, and the University of Cambridge's Faculty of History.

 

Administrative assistance: conferences@crassh.cam.ac.uk

Thursday 3 October

1.00-1.45pm

Registration

1.45-2.00pm

Welcome and opening remarks

2.00-3.30pm

Session 1

Paper 1: Tom Hamilton (History; Durham):
‘Representing Heresy Trials in “the Autumn of the Church”: Paris, 1588’

Paper 2: Daniel Trocmé-Latter (Musicology; Cambridge):
‘A common enemy? The use of anti-Jewish songs during the Reformation period’

3.30-4.00pm

Break

4.00-5.30pm

Keynote 1

Alexandra Walsham (History; Cambridge):
‘Hating Popery at Home: The Material Culture of Anti- Catholicism in Early Modern England’

5.30-7.00pm

Drinks reception

Friday 4 October

9.00-10.30am

Session 2

Paper 1: Grantley McDonald (Musicology; Vienna):
‘Pamphlet wars: English recusants in the Low Countries during John Jewell’s war of words’

Paper 2: Liesbeth Corens (History; QMUL):
‘Conflict and/in Catholic collections: practice and product’

10.30-11.00am

Break

11.00-12.30pm

Keynote 2

Nicholas Thompson (Religious Studies; Auckland):
‘“Who ever thought he belonged to the wrong religion?”Religious pluralism and the definition of heresy in the debate

between Sebastian Castellio (1515–1563) and John Calvin (1509–1564)’

12.30-1.30pm

Lunch

1.30-3.00pm

Session 3

Paper 1: Berthold Kress (History of Art; Warburg Institute):‘Trampling Absent Enemies: Polemical Imagery inMonumental painting’

Paper 2: Debra Strickland (History of Art: Glasgow):
‘Hate and the Humanists: Anti-Semitism in the Nuremberg Chronicle’

3.00-3.30pm

Break

3.30-5.00pm

Session 4

Paper 1: Alison Knight (Literature; CRASSH, Cambridge):‘Migrant rumours: preaching against hate in 1590s London’

Paper 2: John Gallagher (History; Leeds):
‘“Behold the people of the church, behold the Reformedpeople!” Scandal and slander in London’s 16th-century immigrant communities’

5.00-5.30pm

Closing discussion