9 Dec 2022 - 10 Dec 2022All dayRoom SG1, Alison Richard Building, 7 West Road, Cambridge

Description

Convenors

  • Lorenzo Bondioli (University of Cambridge)
  • Michele Campopiano (University of York)
  • Paolo Tedesco (University of Tübingen)

Speakers

  • Rebecca Darley (University of Leeds)
  • Chhaya Goswami (University of Mumbai),
  • Nicholas Matheou (University of Edinburgh)
  • Khodadad Rezakhani (Leiden University)
  • Natasha Issa Shivji (University of Cambridge)
  • Meera Visvanathan (Shiv Nadar University Uttar Pradesh)
  • Deresse Ayenachew Woldetsadik (Debre Berhan University)

Summary

This workshop seeks to re-launch the concept of Mode of Production as a heuristic tool assisting us in addressing a central epistemological problem of the historical discipline: how are we to approach past societies in their immensely varied historical specificity, and how are we to address the relations they entertained with each other? The debate on Modes of Production contributed to redefining the methodology of social and economic history since the late nineteenth century, and in spite of its biases and shortcomings, was key to the framing of pioneering global-historical and comparative approaches, from Samir Amin’s unequal development, to Immanuel Wallerstein’s world-system analysis, Eric Wolf’s Europe and the People without History, and John Haldon’s The State and the Tributary Mode of Production.

The welcome flourishing of global narratives de-centring Europe and disputing many tenets of an old Eurocentric narrative of globalisation, makes the old challenge even more daunting. Historians are thus called to draw meaningful connections between profoundly different societies; at the same time, the cultural turn has to some extent limited the tools to carry out this endeavour, driving attention away from socio-economic questions. As a result, research on global connectedness has so far mostly focused on intercultural exchange, resulting in an often rarefied and depoliticized narrative of “encounter.” The case for interconnectedness across pre-modern Afro-Eurasia thus remains gravely weakened by our limited understanding of the socio-political and socio-economic structures of the societies among which exchange took place.

If creatively redeployed, Mode of Production can help us overcome this obstacle. As a heuristic category, it emphasises how societies mobilised social labour and draws attention at one and the same time to the human relations to the natural environment, the social relations of humans to humans, and the institutional structures of state and society that guide these relations. Thus, Modes of Production is a lens allowing us to emphasise how past societies need to be understood both in their own right and in their reciprocal connections, similarities, and dissimilarities. To this end, the workshop will offer a wide selection of case studies outlining key socio-economic-political structures of societies across Afro-Eurasia beyond Western Europe and before the inception of European capitalist and colonial hegemony.

Supported by:

CRASSH grey logo University of York shield and textPast and present logo

Red line drawing of a tree with University Tubing written underneathDeutsche Forschungsgmeinschaft

Centre for history and economics in a circle of text

 

 

 

 

 

Please contact us for specific accessibility needs, and we will do our best to accommodate any requests.

Programme

9 December
9:30

Registration

10:00

Welcome and introduction

Michele Campopiano (University of York)
‘Modes of production and global history: a methodological assessment.’

10:45

Break

11:00

Session 1

Paolo Tedesco (University of Tübingen)
‘States and tributary modes of production in the Late Roman and Post-Roman Mediterranean’

Lorenzo Bondioli (University of Cambridge)
‘Commercial capital and the tributary mode of production: the case of the Caliphate.’

Nicholas Matheou (University of Edinburgh)
‘Taxation, lordship & nomadic aristocracies: towards a historical typology of tributary regimes of accumulation’

12:30

Break

14:00

Session 2

Khodadad Rezakhani (Leiden University)
‘Floating kingdoms: economy and politics in Post-Sasanian Persian Gulf and the Arabian Sea.’

Meera Visvanathan (Shiv Nadar University Uttar Pradesh)
‘Caste, class and the mode of production debates in South Asia.’

Rebecca Darley (University of Leeds)
Before capitalist hegemony: the case from the Western Indian Ocean (c. 100-1000 CE)

 

15:30

Break

16:00

Session 3

Deresse Ayenachew Woldetsadik (Debre Berhan University)
‘The landowner peasant and a kingdom on his shoulder in Ethiopia.’

Natasha Issa Shivji (University of Cambridge)
‘Modes of production: the East African perspective.’

Chhaya Goswami (University of Mumbai)
‘Merchants and pirates of the Gulf of Kachchh:  coerces of entrepreneurial economic processes and power relations.’

10 December
10:00

Round Table

12:30

Break

Upcoming Events

CENTRE FOR RESEARCH IN THE ARTS, SOCIAL SCIENCES AND HUMANITIES

Tel: +44 1223 766886
Email enquiries@crassh.cam.ac.uk