Rachel’s current project starts from the observation that transformations in matrimonial and contract law traced by legal historians through the sixteenth century have no equivalent in the legislation that defines rape and distinguishes it from other sexual relations. As a result of the Protestant Reformation, sexual practices and contractual arrangements came under renewed scrutiny in early modern Europe, becoming an area of conflict between Protestants and Catholics, and secular and ecclesiastical legal jurisdictions, but this seemingly had little effect on the legal categorisation of ‘rape’.
‘Rape’ is neither an objectively knowable entity, nor an objective category, it is defined in opposition to different forms of ‘legitimate’ sexual relation in historically contingent ways. While legal definitions of rape remain relatively undeveloped in this period, the narrating of sexual crimes in early modern European literature is indicative of a keen social interest in the high stakes of distinguishing rape from other kinds of sex. Take the tales of Lucretia and Philomela as examples, written in the classical period they are numerously adapted in renaissance Italy, France, Spain, and England. In these texts, the stakes of honour make it essential for women and men to distinguish between kinds of sexual relation in more nuanced ways. Rachel’s work situates literary sources, once used to study influence, alongside legal archival documents, within a ‘trajectory of cultural transactions’ (Marrapodi: 2004), and reads literary accounts alongside those of their historical counterparts made available by surviving legal archival documents, in an attempt to substantiate the early modern cultural narrative of rape.
Rachel E. Holmes is a postdoctoral researcher on the ERC-funded project 'Crossroads of Knowledge in Early Modern England: The Place of Literature' at CRASSH/The Faculty of English, at the University of Cambridge and a Junior Research Fellow of Wolfson College.
She works transnationally on early modern European Law and Literature, with a particular focus on marriage, contractual faith, and the difficult status of proof in sexual matters. She is currently revising for publication a monograph on clandestine contracts in early modern European law and literature, which argues that the popularity of the clandestine marriage plot in literature corresponds closely to developments and emerging conflicts in matrimonial and contract law.
As a Research Associate on Crossroads of Knowledge, she is working on a new project that explores the keen social interest in early modern Europe in the high stakes of defining and distinguishing rape from other kinds of sexual contracts.
She is also a co-ordinator of the Centre for Mediaeval and Early Modern Law and Literature, an international law and literature network.
Holmes, Rachel E. & Toria A. Johnson, ed. In Pursuit of Truth: Law and Emotion in Early Modern Europe [Special Issue]. Forum for Modern Language Studies (Forthcoming January 2018). Special issue
Holmes, Rachel E. ‘What’s the Matter? Murderous Husbands and “Adulterous” Wives in Early Modern Drama.’ In Pursuit of Truth: Law and Emotion in Early Modern Europe [Special issue]. Forum for Modern Language Studies (Forthcoming January 2018). Article
Holmes, Rachel E. ‘Shakespeare and the Law: A Conversation Among Disciplines and Professions.’ Shakespeare Newsletter (Forthcoming 2016). Book/Film/Article review
Holmes, Rachel E. 'Christopher N. Warren, Literature and the Law of Nations, 1580–1680. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015. ix + 286 pp. £55.00. ISBN: 978-08719342 (hb).' Renaissance Studies (Forthcoming 2016). doi: 10.1111/rest.12217. Book/Film/Article review
Holmes, Rachel E. ‘Carew, Richard. The Examination of Men’s Wits. Ed. Rocío G. Sumillera. London: MHRA (MHRA Tudor & Stuart Translations, 17), 2014. 375 pp. £14.99/$24.99/€17.49. ISBN 978–1–78188–161–3.’ Forum for Modern Language Studies (April 2015). doi:10.1093/fmls/cqv009. Book/Film/Article review
Holmes, Rachel E. (2017). ‘“‘Hombres como yo no ven / Basta que [...] sospechen’: Knowing Adultery in Renaissance Drama.’ Renaissance Society of America Annual Meeting 2017, Chicago, IL, 31 March–2 April.
Holmes, Rachel E., Subha Mukherji, Elizabeth L. Swann, Tim Stuart-Buttle, Rebecca Tomlin (2016). ‘”Hazarding all”: Risk & Knowledge in Early Modern England. An Interdisciplinary Conversation.’ Scientiae 2016, St Anne’s College, University of Oxford, 5–7 July.
‘ "Partly with truth, partly with fiction": Narrating Rape in Leonard Digges and Gonzalo de Céspedes y Meneses,’ Iberian Literature and Culture in Early Modern England, University of Newcastle, 14-16 July. Invited speaker
Holmes, Rachel E., Subha Mukherji, Elizabeth L. Swann, Tim Stuart-Buttle, Rebecca Tomlin. ‘”Hazarding all': Risk & Knowledge in Early Modern England. An Interdisciplinary Conversation.’ Scientiae 2016, Oxford, 5–7 July. Roundtable participant
'"The deposition of that ravenous viper': The Rhetoric of Rape in Early Modern England and Spain,' Women Negotiating Justice: Britain and Ireland, c.1100–c.1750 Workshop, Cardiff University, 21 April. Speaker
‘”My words express my purpose”: Proof and Consent in the History of Epitia,’ European Social Science History Conference, Valencia, 30 March – 2 April. Invited speaker
'A Widow's Will in Early Modern Adaptations of The Duchess of Amalfi,' Early Modern Interdisciplinary Seminar, University of Cambridge, 10 February. Invited speaker
Can Social Media Work for Me? A Round-table Discussion organised by the Social Media Knowledge Exchange, SG2 Alison Richard Building, Thursday 19 November. Invited speaker
‘”My words express my purpose”: Consent in Renaissance Retellings of the Story of Epitia,’ Historicising Rape, Cardiff University, 8-10 July. Speaker
'Rhetoric and Fiction, Law and Drama: Subha Mukherji "Law, Literature and the Paradox of Dramatic Character" and Quentin Skinner "Why Shylocke Loses His Case: Judicial Rhetoric in The Merchant of Venice,"' The English Legal Imaginary: Part II, University of St Andrews, 1-2 May. Invited chair
The English Legal Imaginary: Part II, University of St Andrews, 1-2 May. Organiser
‘Holy Matrimony? Re-forming Clandestine Marriage in the Tale of the Lovers of Verona,’ Spanish Law and Literature, Renaissance Society of America Annual Meeting 2015, Humboldt University of Berlin, 26-28 March. Speaker
‘Casos de Honra: Clandestine Contracts in Early Modern Europe,’ Early Career and Postgraduate Research, Centre for Mediaeval and Early Modern Law and Literature, University of St Andrews, 16 September. Invited speaker
Crossroads of Knowledge, Researcher
August 2015 - June 2019